{ "record_id": "dar_01M6SJSBK9X3YNB81FVD56TB17", "created_at": "2026-11-06T23:23:32.329Z", "deliberation": { "id": "44f0e02d-adf4-4a55-9397-ed0c7868b76a", "mode_requested": "standard", "path": "COUNCIL", "status": "completed", "halt_reason": "decided", "rounds": 1, "degraded": false, "input_mode": "full_context" }, "inputs": { "question_sha256": "432fbabee8eed5027a2e86e546233fb6725fe37afa9bb60920ad561c93d58f31", "documents": [ { "doc_id": "d1", "document_id": "acea452a-4435-49b6-a969-11bf9e1bd7be", "canonical_key": "/docs/acea452a-4435-49b6-a969-11bf9e1bd7be/canonical-2026.11.2.json", "sha256": "1ed9e1f60c9549060788ec19581846cababc6e6ab2b66ab39e153b7a48547a08", "canonical_sha256": "3efe2e6aa25358208d2c65e190493f8cb57b6e6dcb85914f8d29d24d42f9ba04", "bytes": 8695, "ingest_version": "2026.11.2" } ] }, "policy": { "workspace_id": "b82aaf4c-b448-4bb6-a562-d0b025c01085", "version": 47, "alpha": 0.1, "data_class": "CONFIDENTIAL", "zdr_required": false, "profile": "flagship-azure-aws" }, "prompt_bundle": { "id": "council-2026.11.8", "sha256": "6bdfb5346f492bf3e5e22f7cdf58ae324225f3d1f4e26c32417c80a42fda36a9" }, "settings": { "version": 51, "sha256": "924901773ab846df1fb6a186924bfd8c9a52ffdd0ca9c79e5f5c33a6ca6c33da" }, "models": [ { "slot": "P1", "role": "proposer", "requested": "claude-opus-5-5", "served": "claude-opus-5-5", "served_source": "response", "vendor": "anthropic", "family": "claude", "origin": "US", "region": "us", "regions": [ "us" ], "cloud_region": null, "zdr": "contract", "status": "ok", "usage": { "in": 389, "cache_read": 0, "cache_write": 3723, "out": 1229 }, "cost_usd": 0.044751, "stop_reason": "end_turn", "refusal_fallback_used": false }, { "slot": "P2", "role": "proposer", "requested": "gpt-6.1-sol", "served": "gpt-6.1-sol-2026-09-29", "served_source": "response", "vendor": "openai", "family": "gpt", "origin": "US", "region": "us", "regions": [ "us" ], "cloud_region": null, "zdr": "modified_abuse_monitoring_approval", "status": "ok", "usage": { "in": 2291, "cache_read": 0, "cache_write": 0, "out": 360 }, "cost_usd": 0.008182, "stop_reason": "stop", "refusal_fallback_used": false }, { "slot": "P3", "role": "proposer", "requested": "grok-4.7", "served": "grok-4.7", "served_source": "response", "vendor": "xai", "family": "grok", "origin": "US", "region": "us", "regions": [ "us" ], "cloud_region": null, "zdr": "modified_abuse_monitoring_approval", "status": "ok", "usage": { "in": 2386, "cache_read": 0, "cache_write": 0, "out": 244 }, "cost_usd": 0.006236, "stop_reason": "stop", "refusal_fallback_used": false }, { "slot": "P4", "role": "proposer", "requested": "us.moonshotai.kimi-k3", "served": "us.moonshotai.kimi-k3", "served_source": "request", "vendor": "moonshot", "family": "kimi", "origin": "CN", "region": "us", "regions": [ "us" ], "cloud_region": "us-east-1", "zdr": true, "status": "ok", "usage": { "in": 2525, "cache_read": 0, "cache_write": 0, "out": 1118 }, "cost_usd": 0.02678, "stop_reason": "end_turn", "refusal_fallback_used": false }, { "slot": "AUD", "role": "auditor", "requested": "claude-opus-5-5", "vendor": "anthropic", "region": "us", "regions": [ "us" ], "cloud_region": null }, { "slot": "EXT", "role": "extractor", "requested": "claude-sonnet-5-5", "vendor": "anthropic", "region": "us", "regions": [ "us" ], "cloud_region": null }, { "slot": "MAT", "role": "matcher", "requested": "claude-sonnet-5-5", "vendor": "anthropic", "region": "us", "regions": [ "us" ], "cloud_region": null }, { "slot": "CHR", "role": "chairman", "requested": "claude-opus-5-5", "vendor": "anthropic", "region": "us", "regions": [ "us" ], "cloud_region": null } ], "residency": { "policy_regions": [ "us" ], "processing_regions": [ "us" ], "cloud_regions": [ "us-east-1" ] }, "slot_substitutions": [], "excluded_by_policy": {}, "routing": { "agreement": 0.1818, "tau": null, "tau_version": null, "path": "COUNCIL", "reasons": [ "tau_uncalibrated", "mode=standard" ] }, "claim_graph": { "clusters": [ { "id": "c01", "type": "FACT_FROM_SOURCE", "canonical_text": { "decrypted": "Disclosure of Confidential Information to third parties, other than as permitted, requires the Disclosing Party's prior written approval." }, "asserted_by": [ "P1", "P3", "P4" ], "contradicted_by": [], "grounded": true, "grounding": "exact", "support": 0.97069, "label": "CONTESTED", "verdicts": [ { "judge": "P2", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true } ] }, { "id": "c02", "type": "FACT_FROM_SOURCE", "canonical_text": { "decrypted": "Section 2(b) carves out the Receiving Party's employees, agents, advisors, contractors and other representatives from the bar on third-party disclosure." }, "asserted_by": [ "P1" ], "contradicted_by": [], "grounded": true, "grounding": "exact", "support": 0.98901, "label": "CONTESTED", "verdicts": [ { "judge": "P3", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P2", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P4", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true } ] }, { "id": "c03", "type": "FACT_FROM_SOURCE", "canonical_text": { "decrypted": "Disclosure to advisers and the other carved-out recipients is allowed only if three conditions are met." }, "asserted_by": [ "P1" ], "contradicted_by": [], "grounded": true, "grounding": "exact", "support": 0.98901, "label": "CONTESTED", "verdicts": [ { "judge": "P3", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P2", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P4", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true } ] }, { "id": "c04", "type": "FACT_FROM_SOURCE", "canonical_text": { "decrypted": "Condition 1: the recipient has a reasonable need to know for the Purpose." }, "asserted_by": [ "P1", "P4" ], "contradicted_by": [], "grounded": true, "grounding": "exact", "support": 0.98201, "label": "CONTESTED", "verdicts": [ { "judge": "P3", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P2", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true } ] }, { "id": "c05", "type": "FACT_FROM_SOURCE", "canonical_text": { "decrypted": "By default, the Purpose is evaluating whether to enter into a business relationship." }, "asserted_by": [ "P1", "P2", "P4" ], "contradicted_by": [], "grounded": true, "grounding": "exact", "support": 0.97069, "label": "CONTESTED", "verdicts": [ { "judge": "P3", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true } ] }, { "id": "c06", "type": "FACT_FROM_SOURCE", "canonical_text": { "decrypted": "Condition 2: the recipient is bound by confidentiality obligations no less protective of the Disclosing Party than the applicable MNDA terms." }, "asserted_by": [ "P1", "P4" ], "contradicted_by": [], "grounded": true, "grounding": "exact", "support": 0.98201, "label": "CONTESTED", "verdicts": [ { "judge": "P3", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P2", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true } ] }, { "id": "c07", "type": "FACT_FROM_SOURCE", "canonical_text": { "decrypted": "Condition 3: the Receiving Party remains responsible for the recipient's compliance with the MNDA." }, "asserted_by": [ "P1", "P4" ], "contradicted_by": [], "grounded": true, "grounding": "exact", "support": 0.98201, "label": "CONTESTED", "verdicts": [ { "judge": "P3", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P2", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true } ] }, { "id": "c08", "type": "FACT_FROM_SOURCE", "canonical_text": { "decrypted": "The information may still be used solely for the Purpose." }, "asserted_by": [ "P1" ], "contradicted_by": [], "grounded": true, "grounding": "exact", "support": 0.98901, "label": "CONTESTED", "verdicts": [ { "judge": "P3", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P2", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P4", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true } ] }, { "id": "c09", "type": "FACT_FROM_SOURCE", "canonical_text": { "decrypted": "The information must be protected with at least the Receiving Party's own protections for similar information, and no less than a reasonable standard of care." }, "asserted_by": [ "P1" ], "contradicted_by": [], "grounded": true, "grounding": "exact", "support": 0.98901, "label": "CONTESTED", "verdicts": [ { "judge": "P3", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P2", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P4", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true } ] }, { "id": "c10", "type": "FACT_FROM_SOURCE", "canonical_text": { "decrypted": "The Standard Terms do not mention affiliates." }, "asserted_by": [ "P1" ], "contradicted_by": [], "grounded": true, "grounding": "exact", "support": 0.98901, "label": "CONTESTED", "verdicts": [ { "judge": "P3", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P2", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P4", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true } ] }, { "id": "c11", "type": "FACT_FROM_SOURCE", "canonical_text": { "decrypted": "There is no express affiliate carve-out in the Standard Terms." }, "asserted_by": [ "P1" ], "contradicted_by": [], "grounded": true, "grounding": "exact", "support": 0.98901, "label": "CONTESTED", "verdicts": [ { "judge": "P3", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P2", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P4", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true } ] }, { "id": "c12", "type": "INFERENCE", "canonical_text": { "decrypted": "An affiliate could arguably fall within \"other representatives\", for example if acting as an agent or adviser." }, "asserted_by": [ "P1" ], "contradicted_by": [], "grounded": true, "grounding": "exact", "support": 0.97069, "label": "CONTESTED", "verdicts": [ { "judge": "P3", "round": 1, "verdict": "INSUFFICIENT", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P2", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P4", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true } ] }, { "id": "c13", "type": "CAVEAT", "canonical_text": { "decrypted": "The document does not settle whether an affiliate falls within \"other representatives\"." }, "asserted_by": [ "P1" ], "contradicted_by": [], "grounded": true, "grounding": "exact", "support": 0.98901, "label": "ADVISORY", "verdicts": [ { "judge": "P3", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P2", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P4", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true } ] }, { "id": "c14", "type": "INFERENCE", "canonical_text": { "decrypted": "Otherwise, disclosure to an affiliate requires the disclosing party's prior written approval." }, "asserted_by": [ "P1", "P2", "P4" ], "contradicted_by": [], "grounded": true, "grounding": "exact", "support": 0.97069, "label": "CONTESTED", "verdicts": [ { "judge": "P3", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true } ] }, { "id": "c15", "type": "RECOMMENDATION", "canonical_text": { "decrypted": "Parties wanting an express affiliate right can add one as a modification on the Cover Page." }, "asserted_by": [ "P1" ], "contradicted_by": [], "grounded": true, "grounding": "exact", "support": 0.98901, "label": "ADVISORY", "verdicts": [ { "judge": "P3", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P2", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P4", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true } ] }, { "id": "c16", "type": "FACT_FROM_SOURCE", "canonical_text": { "decrypted": "The Cover Page controls over the Standard Terms." }, "asserted_by": [ "P1" ], "contradicted_by": [], "grounded": true, "grounding": "exact", "support": 0.98901, "label": "CONTESTED", "verdicts": [ { "judge": "P3", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P2", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P4", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true } ] }, { "id": "c17", "type": "FACT_FROM_SOURCE", "canonical_text": { "decrypted": "Advisers may receive Confidential Information without prior written approval if they have a reasonable need to know for the Purpose, are bound by confidentiality obligations no less protective than the applicable MNDA terms, and the receiving party remains responsible for their compliance." }, "asserted_by": [ "P2" ], "contradicted_by": [], "grounded": true, "grounding": "exact", "support": 0.98901, "label": "CONTESTED", "verdicts": [ { "judge": "AUD", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P4", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P1", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true } ] }, { "id": "c18", "type": "FACT_FROM_SOURCE", "canonical_text": { "decrypted": "Affiliates are not expressly listed as permitted recipients of Confidential Information." }, "asserted_by": [ "P2" ], "contradicted_by": [], "grounded": true, "grounding": "exact", "support": 0.98901, "label": "CONTESTED", "verdicts": [ { "judge": "AUD", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P4", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P1", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true } ] }, { "id": "c19", "type": "INFERENCE", "canonical_text": { "decrypted": "An affiliate could receive information under the same exception if it qualifies as an agent, contractor or other representative and satisfies the exception's conditions." }, "asserted_by": [ "P2", "P4" ], "contradicted_by": [], "grounded": true, "grounding": "exact", "support": 0.99331, "label": "CONTESTED", "verdicts": [ { "judge": "P3", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "AUD", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P1", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true } ] }, { "id": "c20", "type": "INFERENCE", "canonical_text": { "decrypted": "Affiliate status alone does not establish permission to receive Confidential Information." }, "asserted_by": [ "P2" ], "contradicted_by": [], "grounded": true, "grounding": "exact", "support": 0.98901, "label": "CONTESTED", "verdicts": [ { "judge": "AUD", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P4", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P1", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true } ] }, { "id": "c21", "type": "FACT_FROM_SOURCE", "canonical_text": { "decrypted": "Advisers may receive Confidential Information under the MNDA only if they have a reasonable need to know for the Purpose." }, "asserted_by": [ "P3" ], "contradicted_by": [], "grounded": true, "grounding": "exact", "support": 0.98901, "label": "CONTESTED", "verdicts": [ { "judge": "AUD", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P4", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P1", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true } ] }, { "id": "c22", "type": "FACT_FROM_SOURCE", "canonical_text": { "decrypted": "Advisers may receive Confidential Information only if they are bound by confidentiality obligations no less protective than those in the MNDA." }, "asserted_by": [ "P3" ], "contradicted_by": [], "grounded": true, "grounding": "exact", "support": 0.98901, "label": "CONTESTED", "verdicts": [ { "judge": "AUD", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P4", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P1", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true } ] }, { "id": "c23", "type": "FACT_FROM_SOURCE", "canonical_text": { "decrypted": "The Receiving Party remains responsible for its advisers' compliance with the confidentiality obligations." }, "asserted_by": [ "P3" ], "contradicted_by": [], "grounded": true, "grounding": "exact", "support": 0.98901, "label": "CONTESTED", "verdicts": [ { "judge": "AUD", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P4", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P1", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true } ] }, { "id": "c24", "type": "FACT_FROM_SOURCE", "canonical_text": { "decrypted": "The MNDA does not specifically authorize disclosure of Confidential Information to affiliates." }, "asserted_by": [ "P3" ], "contradicted_by": [], "grounded": true, "grounding": "exact", "support": 0.98901, "label": "CONTESTED", "verdicts": [ { "judge": "AUD", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P4", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P1", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true } ] }, { "id": "c25", "type": "FACT_FROM_SOURCE", "canonical_text": { "decrypted": "The requirement of prior written approval for third-party disclosure is subject to the listed representative exception." }, "asserted_by": [ "P3" ], "contradicted_by": [], "grounded": true, "grounding": "exact", "support": 0.98901, "label": "CONTESTED", "verdicts": [ { "judge": "AUD", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P4", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P1", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true } ] }, { "id": "c26", "type": "FACT_FROM_SOURCE", "canonical_text": { "decrypted": "Section 2(b) carves out an exception allowing the Receiving Party to share Confidential Information with its employees, agents, advisors, contractors and other representatives." }, "asserted_by": [ "P4" ], "contradicted_by": [], "grounded": true, "grounding": "exact", "support": 0.98901, "label": "CONTESTED", "verdicts": [ { "judge": "P2", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "AUD", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P1", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true } ] }, { "id": "c27", "type": "FACT_FROM_SOURCE", "canonical_text": { "decrypted": "The carve-out in Section 2(b) is subject to three cumulative conditions." }, "asserted_by": [ "P4" ], "contradicted_by": [], "grounded": true, "grounding": "exact", "support": 0.98901, "label": "CONTESTED", "verdicts": [ { "judge": "P2", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "AUD", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P1", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true } ] }, { "id": "c28", "type": "FACT_FROM_SOURCE", "canonical_text": { "decrypted": "The clause expressly names \"advisors\" but does not expressly use the word \"affiliates\"." }, "asserted_by": [ "P4" ], "contradicted_by": [], "grounded": true, "grounding": "exact", "support": 0.98901, "label": "CONTESTED", "verdicts": [ { "judge": "P3", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P2", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "AUD", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true } ] }, { "id": "c29", "type": "FACT_FROM_SOURCE", "canonical_text": { "decrypted": "The term \"Purpose\" is defined on the Cover Page." }, "asserted_by": [ "P4" ], "contradicted_by": [], "grounded": true, "grounding": "exact", "support": 0.98901, "label": "CONTESTED", "verdicts": [ { "judge": "P2", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "AUD", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true }, { "judge": "P1", "round": 1, "verdict": "SUPPORTED", "quote_valid": true } ] } ] }, "ranking": { "claim_score_winner": "P3", "claim_scores": { "P1": 0.9823, "P2": 0.9836, "P3": 0.986, "P4": 0.9825 }, "borda": { "P1": 1.0, "P2": 0.3333, "P3": 0.0, "P4": 0.6667 }, "kemeny": [ "P1", "P4", "P2", "P3" ], "condorcet": "P1", "bt": null, "low_consensus": true }, "bias_certificate": { "blinding": { "assignment_seed": 6569114505718569, "alias_scheme": "per-reviewer random claim+candidate aliases", "chairman_blind": true, "alias_map_sha256": "125cd7be4a98208b1d92662e1eb2956936b810fe48173dc71473b07a1d7e2bfa" }, "self_exclusion": { "excluded_self_votes": {}, "self_vote_leaks": 0 }, "position": { "pairwise_bt": "not_run" }, "length": { "phi": "not_applied (listwise only; offline phi fitting pending, A12)" }, "judge_weights": { "P1": 1.0, "P2": 1.0, "P3": 1.0, "P4": 1.0, "AUD": 1.0 }, "fabricated_quotes": { "P3": 0, "P2": 0, "AUD": 0, "P4": 0, "P1": 0 }, "aggregation_agreement": { "low_consensus": true, "claim_score_winner": "P3", "kemeny_top": "P1" }, "calibration": { "valid": false, "version": null, "alpha": 0.1, "n": null, "t_verified": null, "invalid_reason": "no_calibration" }, "routing": { "agreement": 0.1818, "tau": null, "path": "COUNCIL" }, "halting": { "rounds": 1, "reason": "decided" } }, "synthesis": { "answer": { "decrypted": "**Advisers may receive Confidential Information without prior approval if they have a reasonable need to know for the Purpose, are bound by equally protective confidentiality obligations, and the Receiving Party stays responsible for them; affiliates are not expressly permitted and need either to qualify as a representative meeting those conditions or the Disclosing Party's prior written approval.**\n\nAdvisers: yes, without asking first, as long as three conditions are met. Affiliates are not expressly listed as permitted recipients, and being an affiliate does not by itself give permission to receive the information. The receiving party must \"not disclose Confidential Information to third parties without the Disclosing Party’s prior written approval, except that the Receiving Party may disclose Confidential Information to its employees, agents, advisors, contractors and other representatives having a reasonable need to know for the Purpose\". That exception comes with three conditions, and all of them must be met:\n1. **Need to know.** The adviser has \"a reasonable need to know for the Purpose\". The Purpose is set on the Cover Page. The template default is \"Evaluating whether to enter into a business relationship with the other party.\"\n2. **Equivalent confidentiality.** The adviser is \"bound by confidentiality obligations no less protective of the Disclosing Party than the applicable terms in this MNDA\". 3. **Continuing responsibility.** \"the Receiving Party remains responsible for their compliance with this MNDA\". The general duties still apply to anything shared:\n- the information may be used \"solely for the Purpose\";\n- it must be protected with at least the receiving party's own protections for similar information, \"but no less than a reasonable standard of care.\"\n\n**Affiliates**\n\nThe clause expressly names \"advisors\" but does not expressly use the word \"affiliates\". Affiliate status alone therefore does not establish permission. - Whether an affiliate counts as an \"other representative\" is not settled by the document. - Otherwise, sharing with an affiliate needs the disclosing party's prior written approval. **Practical point**\n\nIf the parties want a clear right to share with affiliates, the natural place to add it is the Cover Page. The agreement says \"Any modifications of the Standard Terms should be made on the Cover Page, which will control over conflicts with the Standard Terms.\"" }, "violations": 2, "repaired": true, "skipped": false }, "attribution": [ { "member": "P1", "contribution": 0.0, "flipped": [] }, { "member": "P2", "contribution": 0.0, "flipped": [] }, { "member": "P3", "contribution": 0.0, "flipped": [] }, { "member": "P4", "contribution": 0.0, "flipped": [] }, { "member": "AUD", "contribution": 0.0, "flipped": [] } ], "dissent_report": { "contested": [ { "cluster": "c01", "for": [ "P1", "P3", "P4" ], "against": [], "summary": { "decrypted": "1 of 1 reviewers support it; 0 refute it." } }, { "cluster": "c02", "for": [ "P1" ], "against": [], "summary": { "decrypted": "3 of 3 reviewers support it; 0 refute it." } }, { "cluster": "c03", "for": [ "P1" ], "against": [], "summary": { "decrypted": "3 of 3 reviewers support it; 0 refute it." } }, { "cluster": "c04", "for": [ "P1", "P4" ], "against": [], "summary": { "decrypted": "2 of 2 reviewers support it; 0 refute it." } }, { "cluster": "c05", "for": [ "P1", "P2", "P4" ], "against": [], "summary": { "decrypted": "1 of 1 reviewers support it; 0 refute it." } }, { "cluster": "c06", "for": [ "P1", "P4" ], "against": [], "summary": { "decrypted": "2 of 2 reviewers support it; 0 refute it." } }, { "cluster": "c07", "for": [ "P1", "P4" ], "against": [], "summary": { "decrypted": "2 of 2 reviewers support it; 0 refute it." } }, { "cluster": "c08", "for": [ "P1" ], "against": [], "summary": { "decrypted": "3 of 3 reviewers support it; 0 refute it." } }, { "cluster": "c09", "for": [ "P1" ], "against": [], "summary": { "decrypted": "3 of 3 reviewers support it; 0 refute it." } }, { "cluster": "c10", "for": [ "P1" ], "against": [], "summary": { "decrypted": "3 of 3 reviewers support it; 0 refute it." } }, { "cluster": "c11", "for": [ "P1" ], "against": [], "summary": { "decrypted": "3 of 3 reviewers support it; 0 refute it." } }, { "cluster": "c12", "for": [ "P1" ], "against": [], "summary": { "decrypted": "2 of 3 reviewers support it; 0 refute it; 1 found the evidence insufficient." } }, { "cluster": "c14", "for": [ "P1", "P2", "P4" ], "against": [], "summary": { "decrypted": "1 of 1 reviewers support it; 0 refute it." } }, { "cluster": "c16", "for": [ "P1" ], "against": [], "summary": { "decrypted": "3 of 3 reviewers support it; 0 refute it." } }, { "cluster": "c17", "for": [ "P2" ], "against": [], "summary": { "decrypted": "3 of 3 reviewers support it; 0 refute it." } }, { "cluster": "c18", "for": [ "P2" ], "against": [], "summary": { "decrypted": "3 of 3 reviewers support it; 0 refute it." } }, { "cluster": "c19", "for": [ "P2", "P4" ], "against": [], "summary": { "decrypted": "3 of 3 reviewers support it; 0 refute it." } }, { "cluster": "c20", "for": [ "P2" ], "against": [], "summary": { "decrypted": "3 of 3 reviewers support it; 0 refute it." } }, { "cluster": "c21", "for": [ "P3" ], "against": [], "summary": { "decrypted": "3 of 3 reviewers support it; 0 refute it." } }, { "cluster": "c22", "for": [ "P3" ], "against": [], "summary": { "decrypted": "3 of 3 reviewers support it; 0 refute it." } }, { "cluster": "c23", "for": [ "P3" ], "against": [], "summary": { "decrypted": "3 of 3 reviewers support it; 0 refute it." } }, { "cluster": "c24", "for": [ "P3" ], "against": [], "summary": { "decrypted": "3 of 3 reviewers support it; 0 refute it." } }, { "cluster": "c25", "for": [ "P3" ], "against": [], "summary": { "decrypted": "3 of 3 reviewers support it; 0 refute it." } }, { "cluster": "c26", "for": [ "P4" ], "against": [], "summary": { "decrypted": "3 of 3 reviewers support it; 0 refute it." } }, { "cluster": "c27", "for": [ "P4" ], "against": [], "summary": { "decrypted": "3 of 3 reviewers support it; 0 refute it." } }, { "cluster": "c28", "for": [ "P4" ], "against": [], "summary": { "decrypted": "3 of 3 reviewers support it; 0 refute it." } }, { "cluster": "c29", "for": [ "P4" ], "against": [], "summary": { "decrypted": "3 of 3 reviewers support it; 0 refute it." } } ] }, "cost": { "usd": 0.57676, "credits": 10 }, "schema": "danphe.dar/1.1", "seq": 1469, "prev_sha256": "4edf9c8392a32ac861e84f1108537d465e6ffdb0c48ba216d1d6b3010712e14d", "record_sha256": "837c82ae80ca3988223f2caaff91f30a1ab2ba6a4dd7bbc6445ee26f1c6c18a8", "_published": "Public copy of the audit record (DAR) of this example run. Removed for publication: tenant and user identifiers, cloud endpoint host names and vendor request ids; encrypted fields are shown decrypted. Because of these edits the file no longer hashes to record_sha256, which identifies the stored, unedited record. The run was recorded on the Danphe Council development stack with live model calls; its signature uses the development key." }